How to Negotiate the Subrogation Claim | Step By Step Guide


The contents of this web page are for informational and educational purposes only, and nothing you read is intended to be legal advice. Please review our disclaimer before taking action based upon anything you read or see.

Subrogation is an intricate legal process with canons that often bemuse people. Usually, people who don’t turn to legal beagles for subrogation feel hoodwinked at the end of the process. Therefore one must consult legal advisors when hooked in this kind of situation. Now here, our purpose is to help you out in this situation and provide you contrivance for negotiating the subrogation claim. Let’s find out how to negotiate the subrogation claim.

Subrogation can be a difficult situation to deal with. It’s important for insurance companies and other types of third-party providers that are involved in the process. However, not just because they’re being owed money or have rights on your behalf either!

At this point, you’ve probably got questions about what subrogation is all about. So, let me break down its definition quickly, so no more surprises are coming up later when things get worse than you think.

What is Subrogation?

How to Negotiate the Subrogation Claim

((Subrogation)) is a legal right term that insurance companies hold to chase the loss-causing party to the party who had a loss, unfortunately. It is a way of making the process of settlement easier under the insurance policy.

Application of Subrogation Process

Subrogation has most of its application in the insurance sector. It is a contract between the client (insurer) and the insurance company which contains, in a sense, a particular type of clause that acts as a support in recovering the amount of insurance claim. They use this right to recover the amount of loss from the party responsible for causing it, before or after compensating their client (who had that respective damage or loss).

Understanding Your Current Situation

First of all, you must be aware that in most situations, the party’s insurance company that got the damage pays for their client’s claim; after that, it turns to the party responsible for damage for reimbursement. 

But do remember that there are some clauses in which neither the party who caused loss nor their insurance company will be responsible. These clauses are the ones protecting insurance companies in this situation.

Colorado Law for Subrogation

((Colorado includes laws)) that have the purpose of cushioning the party suffering from loss or damage from having to reimburse the insurance company for the losses they got. This Color law makes the process of subrogation a bit easier. The target of the subrogation process should always be to cushion the injured party.

Limitations for Subrogation Process

Many state laws limit subrogation to one-third of your total settlement if you involve an attorney, or one-half of yours, for settlement without an attorney. This is to protect the one from challenging situations where you might not receive anything after the subrogation process and guarantees that you will obtain none less than one-third of the settlement.

Negotiating Tactics for Subrogation Process

How to Negotiate the Subrogation Claim

In fact, the insurance company always desires to resolve the proceedings quickly as possible. Most of the time, an expert negotiator is the one who works to get the insurance provider to reduce the amount as tiny as possible of their subrogation claim to the extent. 

Style matters

The skills of negotiation are the tools of the adjuster or attorney. The ratio of profit only depends on the ability to negotiate. The negotiation power maximizes the profit and recovery potential. ((95% to 99%)) of cases have a great outcome without litigation.

All the profit depends on negotiation, which helps you determine the matter reaping away from the trial. If you want to be the best negotiator, you will be building on a skillset applicable to almost every part of your job. Subrogation negotiation depends upon the origin of the cases.

These entire are happening of the cases and the persons involved in the circumstances. Most adjusters and attorneys make the same blunders that they immediately do transactional bargaining, whereas they have to establish a relationship with their counterparts.

A wise step

You should create the atmosphere so that both parties feel their success, but that doesn’t mean you have to take less amount but pretend that you are a well-wisher of both sides. Your argument should make them realize that you allow them to sell their acceptance as a mutual win.


You should never forget that proper communication with the insurance company is a fundamental key here; you should be well aware of every step taken; otherwise, it will be legally incorrect.

Attorney fees

Your step should be to try hard to remove attorney fees from settlement, making your burden less about the claim.

Insurance companies like State Farm, ((GEICO)), and Allstate are present, trying to process these claims. The subrogation attorneys require a small percentage of the money. That money they will recover by making subrogation claims. So these law firms possessing subrogation departments work to settle them as quickly as possible and get the money they want. This creates an excellent opportunity to settle at a low price. 

Read More: What Are Different Positions In A Law Firm

Acceptance of offer

Why would anyone accept an offer that is solely beneficial for you? This should be pretended to the others that negotiation is 100% profitable for both.

To fulfill this activity, you need the time to make this victory for both sides. How can they realize that they are also in profit while paying the total value of your satisfaction? As more money will catch more flies, many tips and tricks to build a smooth relationship. On the other hand, a skilled negotiator can reduce the subrogation by a couple of percentage points.

Tips for Negotiating the Subrogation Claim

A waiver of subrogation is an agreement to prevent the client from going after the damage-causing party.

  • The party that has caused loss hopes the uninsured carrier waives the right to subrogate, which quickly gets them off for any subrogation claim. A waiver of subrogation is an agreement that prevents the insurer from going after the at-fault driver.
  • The at-fault driver hopes the uninsured/underinsured carrier waives the right to subrogate, which gets them off the hook for any subrogation claim.
  • If the insurer has a valid claim and you don’t pay, a judgment may be entered against you. Ignoring a subrogation letter will not make the problem go away.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you settle a subrogation claim?

For the settlement of the claim, California Law states it’s the right of the injured party to receive compensation for their losses for sure before the victim’s insurance company. The victim’s insurance company can be helpful in the settlement for subrogation.

The whole settlement for the victim should be provided before proceeding to the loss-causing party.

How do you fight the claim?

The best way for the field subrogation claim against you is to settle down out of the court. It is the easiest way to negotiate subrogation claims, and this way would be beneficial for both parties so that they will be free to pay the cost associated with litigation.

Do I have to pay a subrogation claim?

Subrogation is the recovered money from the insurance company. If a person’s car is insured, then the subrogation should be paid by the insurance company. The company will only pay when their policyholder is not a mistake/ fault. The other condition is that if the drivers have insurance, their companies are responsible for subrogation.

How do you negotiate a settlement with an insurance claim adjuster?

There are some ways to get the best settlement offer from the company. You should nominate the person as an attorney. Now you have to arrange and provide all the extensive documentation and evidence to your attorney. It would be best if you had emotional care, so you should seek emotional distress.

Otherwise, it takes so long to come out of the trauma. Always try to make them offer you more so that it can be more beneficial for you. If you accept the first offer, maybe you will regret it later. It would be best if you left it or pushed the adjuster to make a justified offer.

The adjuster should be compelled to offer you the best. As every request should be treated, the confirmed offer should be treated. The guaranteed offer has to be discussed and then taken in written form. It will be beneficial for you in the future. 

What happens if I reject a settlement offer?

After the refusal of the offer, then the settlement offer will have vanished. You must know that once you reject a settlement offer, there is no coming back.

Rejecting an offer is an unwise and dangerous legal choice. It is always advised that you should consult an experienced legal advisor before declining a request. So that he should suggest a better way to handle the situation rather than making decisions in haste because simply if you lose a settlement offer, that means you are forcing your case to go to trial.

If the insurer’s claims are valid and you didn’t pay, in case of that, then there will be a judgment entered against you. Trust us that ignoring a subrogation is not the right way to get rid of this situation. 


Subrogation is a confusing process that nobody can fret over. It is an obscure concept to the general public. An ordinary person can be angry when he gets to know that he has to negotiate for insurance. Every insurance policy has a subrogation clause, and a person should prepare himself for the case’s potential outcome, which is the easiest way to negotiate leverage.

Comments are closed.